Wind Energy News
WIND DAILY
Why US offshore wind power is struggling - the good, the bad and the opportunity
illustration only
Why US offshore wind power is struggling - the good, the bad and the opportunity
by Christopher Niezrecki | Director of the Center for Energy Innovation, UMass Lowell
Boston MA (SPX) May 10, 2024

America's first large-scale offshore wind farms began sending power to the Northeast in early 2024, but a wave of wind farm project cancellations and rising costs have left many people with doubts about the industry's future in the U.S.

Several big hitters, including Orsted, Equinor, BP and Avangrid, have canceled contracts or sought to renegotiate them in recent months. Pulling out meant the companies faced cancellation penalties ranging from US$16 million to several hundred million dollars per project. It also resulted in Siemens Energy, the world's largest maker of offshore wind turbines, anticipating financial losses in 2024 of around $2.2 billion.

Altogether, projects that had been canceled by the end of 2023 were expected to total more than 12 gigawatts of power, representing more than half of the capacity in the project pipeline.

So, what happened, and can the U.S. offshore wind industry recover?

I lead UMass Lowell's Center for Wind Energy Science Technology and Research WindSTAR and Center for Energy Innovation and follow the industry closely. The offshore wind industry's troubles are complicated, but it's far from dead in the U.S., and some policy changes may help it find firmer footing.

Long approval process's cascade of challenges
Getting offshore wind projects permitted and approved in the U.S. takes years and is fraught with uncertainty for developers, more so than in Europe or Asia.

Before a company bids on a U.S. project, the developer must plan the procurement of the entire wind farm, including making reservations to purchase components such as turbines and cables, construction equipment and ships. The bid must also be cost-competitive, so companies have a tendency to bid low and not anticipate unexpected costs, which adds to financial uncertainty and risk.

The winning U.S. bidder then purchases an expensive ocean lease, costing in the hundreds of millions of dollars. But it has no right to build a wind project yet.

Before starting to build, the developer must conduct site assessments to determine what kind of foundations are possible and identify the scale of the project. The developer must consummate an agreement to sell the power it produces, identify a point of interconnection to the power grid, and then prepare a construction and operation plan, which is subject to further environmental review. All of that takes about five years, and it's only the beginning.

For a project to move forward, developers may need to secure dozens of permits from local, tribal, state, regional and federal agencies. The federal Bureau of Ocean Energy Management, which has jurisdiction over leasing and management of the seabed, must consult with agencies that have regulatory responsibilities over different aspects in the ocean, such as the armed forces, Environmental Protection Agency and National Marine Fisheries Service, as well as groups including commercial and recreational fishing, Indigenous groups, shipping, harbor managers and property owners.

For Vineyard Wind I - which began sending power from five of its 62 planned wind turbines off Martha's Vineyard in early 2024 - the time from BOEM's lease auction to getting its first electricity to the grid was about nine years.

Costs can balloon during the regulatory delays
Until recently, these contracts didn't include any mechanisms to adjust for rising supply costs during the long approval time, adding to the risk for developers.

From the time today's projects were bid to the time they were approved for construction, the world dealt with the COVID-19 pandemic, inflation, global supply chain problems, increased financing costs and the war in Ukraine. Steep increases in commodity prices, including for steel and copper, as well as in construction and operating costs, made many contracts signed years earlier no longer financially viable.

New and re-bid contracts are now allowing for price adjustments after the environmental approvals have been given, which is making projects more attractive to developers in the U.S. Many of the companies that canceled projects are now rebidding.

The regulatory process is becoming more streamlined, but it still takes about six years, while other countries are building projects at a faster pace and larger scale.

Shipping rules, power connections
Another significant hurdle for offshore wind development in the U.S. involves a century-old law known as the Jones Act.

The Jones Act requires vessels carrying cargo between U.S. points to be U.S.-built, U.S.-operated and U.S.-owned. It was written to boost the shipping industry after World War I. However, there are only three offshore wind turbine installation vessels in the world that are large enough for the turbines proposed for U.S. projects, and none are compliant with the Jones Act.

That means wind turbine components must be transported by smaller barges from U.S. ports and then installed by a foreign installation vessel waiting offshore, which raises the cost and likelihood of delays.

Dominion Energy is building a new ship, the Charybdis, that will comply with the Jones Act. But a typical offshore wind farm needs over 25 different types of vessels - for crew transfers, surveying, environmental monitoring, cable-laying, heavy lifting and many other roles.

The nation also lacks a well-trained workforce for manufacturing, construction and operation of offshore wind farms.

For power to flow from offshore wind farms, the electricity grid also requires significant upgrades. The Department of Energy is working on regional transmission plans, but permitting will undoubtedly be slow.

Lawsuits, disinformation add to the challenges
Numerous lawsuits from advocacy groups that oppose offshore wind projects have further slowed development.

Wealthy homeowners have tried to stop wind farms that might appear in their ocean view. Astroturfing groups that claim to be advocates of the environment, but are actually supported by fossil fuel industry interests, have launched disinformation campaigns.

In 2023, many Republican politicians and conservative groups immediately cast blame for whale deaths off the coast of New York and New Jersey on the offshore wind developers, but the evidence points instead to increased ship traffic collisions and entanglements with fishing gear.

Such disinformation can reduce public support and slow projects' progress.

Efforts to keep the offshore wind industry going
The Biden administration set a goal to install 30 gigawatts of offshore wind capacity by 2030, but recent estimates indicate that the actual number will be closer to half that.

Despite the challenges, developers have reason to move ahead.

The Inflation Reduction Act provides incentives, including federal tax credits for the development of clean energy projects and for developers that build port facilities in locations that previously relied on fossil fuel industries. Most coastal state governments are also facilitating projects by allowing for a price readjustment after environmental approvals have been given. They view offshore wind as an opportunity for economic growth.

These financial benefits can make building an offshore wind industry more attractive to companies that need market stability and a pipeline of projects to help lower costs - projects that can create jobs and boost economic growth and a cleaner environment.

Related Links
University of Massachusetts
Wind Energy News at Wind Daily

Subscribe Free To Our Daily Newsletters
Tweet

RELATED CONTENT
The following news reports may link to other Space Media Network websites.
WIND DAILY
Robots enhance wind turbine blade production at NREL
Los Angeles CA (SPX) May 03, 2024
The U.S. Department of Energy's National Renewable Energy Laboratory (NREL) has incorporated robotic technology into the production of wind turbine blades, aiming to reduce hazardous working conditions and enhance product consistency. Robots, which have been utilized in the wind energy sector for tasks such as painting and polishing, are now being employed for more complex operations like trimming, grinding, and sanding the blades. "I would consider it a success," stated Hunter Huth, a robotics en ... read more

WIND DAILY
Fuel rods from GE Vernova's Nuclear Fuels are under evaluation at Oak Ridge

Sam Altman-backed nuclear start-up crashes after Wall Street debut

France's next-gen nuclear reactor gets green light

France's EDF, Korea's KHNP bid in Czech nuclear tender

WIND DAILY
Today at the CPUC: SDG&E's Revised Tariff Plans Under Scrutiny

UC Santa Barbara innovates room temperature process for perovskite solar cells

DGIST team sheds light on mechanisms enhancing efficiency in thin-film solar cells

Today at the CPUC: Legislative Lifeline for Ratepayers as AB 1999 Amends Utility Tax

WIND DAILY
New Insights into the Slow Process of Breaking Down Plant Material for Biofuels

Chicken fat transformed into supercapacitor components

Kimchi Institute process upcycles cabbage byproducts into bioplastics

Major advancement in sustainable syngas production using solar power

WIND DAILY
US, China pledge joint methane action at climate talks

Australia unveils plan to keep burning gas beyond 2050

Octogenarian Just Stop Oil protesters target Britain's Magna Carta

Manganese and iridium catalyst marks significant advance in sustainable hydrogen production

WIND DAILY
Biden's clean energy tax credits likely to remain 'law of the land': Brainard

US banking giants had 'significant' challenges estimating climate risks: Fed

Solar storm could bring auroras, power and telecoms disruptions

Ukraine limits energy supplies after 'massive' Russian strike

WIND DAILY
Quantum advances enhance understanding of high-temperature superconductors

US forges new 'battery belt' in hopes of electric future

China issues draft guidelines to rein in lithium battery industry

A model for Australia's cost-effective renewable energy grid transformation

WIND DAILY
US to raise tariffs on Chinese electric vehicles: report

Nissan net profit nearly doubles despite China challenges

Clashes as protesters try to force entry into German Tesla plant

BMW says EU probe into China EV subsidies against free trade

WIND DAILY
Changing farming practices could cut almost one third of global emissions: World Bank

Mongolia's wildlife at risk from overgrazing

Chad's cotton farmers burned by climate change and false promises

Seeds from China's space station tested in agricultural experiments

Subscribe Free To Our Daily Newsletters




The content herein, unless otherwise known to be public domain, are Copyright 1995-2024 - Space Media Network. All websites are published in Australia and are solely subject to Australian law and governed by Fair Use principals for news reporting and research purposes. AFP, UPI and IANS news wire stories are copyright Agence France-Presse, United Press International and Indo-Asia News Service. ESA news reports are copyright European Space Agency. All NASA sourced material is public domain. Additional copyrights may apply in whole or part to other bona fide parties. All articles labeled "by Staff Writers" include reports supplied to Space Media Network by industry news wires, PR agencies, corporate press officers and the like. Such articles are individually curated and edited by Space Media Network staff on the basis of the report's information value to our industry and professional readership. Advertising does not imply endorsement, agreement or approval of any opinions, statements or information provided by Space Media Network on any Web page published or hosted by Space Media Network. General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) Statement Our advertisers use various cookies and the like to deliver the best ad banner available at one time. All network advertising suppliers have GDPR policies (Legitimate Interest) that conform with EU regulations for data collection. By using our websites you consent to cookie based advertising. If you do not agree with this then you must stop using the websites from May 25, 2018. Privacy Statement. Additional information can be found here at About Us.